Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
The Sun Is by Nanhart The Sun Is by Nanhart


Full Title: The Sun is a Mass of Incandescent Gas
“The winners are the ones who get to write the history books....”

Dear Princess Celestia,
I hate drawing/colouring your hair. SO MUCH.
Your (somewhat) faithful fan, Me.

Because I have the hardest time trying to foal myself into believing a moon can withstand the sun, let alone magical pony interpretations of it. That, and I love the theories of Princess Celestia being a tyrant and unable to understand friendship given her position as a literal god for hundreds of years (not that I don't enjoy the calm/giving leader side as well, episode 26 ftw).

I don't think of her as evil. In my personal head canon I like the idea that she just lost her ability to emphasize with mortals. The sun is large and very powerful, best to only have dealings from afar. The moon weaker, closer to our planet and protects us from meteors and other harm from space.

EDIT HOLY CRAP SO MANY FAVES+COMMENTS :faint: Since I drew/wrote this with vague in mind, it's not my place to tell you what to think, but I will tell you what I was aiming for, which is:

:iconalfalfamonster2plz:1) Celestia is not evil (for this comic's propose anyways XD). Her powers have become what we are to ants. Huge, powerful, unrelatable from either side. So no, she's not a 'demon' (in western or eastern sense) nor is she a dragon (too weak to match to her strength). While those who are not used to dealing with fangs and claws can make for a frightening appearance, this shouldn't be what makes 'evil'.

:iconlunamadplz: 2)She is still transforming. Her pony body cannot handle her powers and is transforming to a more stable state where she can handle it. Think Otomo's Akira.

:iconsishoof: 3)Celestia is holding/carrying Twilight, not crushing her. It wasn't my intention, but since somepony brought it up, I realize it could look very much like that as well. Twilight's face was suppose to be of one shocked/terrified from the events of before and what is unfolding in front of her.

:iconcelestiaorlyplz:4)If Celestia wanted Twilight dead this comic would be a whole lot shorter. Because even if I was going to play the "evil" card, I think Celestia's too genre savvy to dare risk a chance with a pony that clearly has amazing powers herself.

FOR THOSE WHO NEED BACKSTORY, Here is a taste of my WIP story idea (please keep in mind a lot of this is probably going to change in the official comic):

Celestia is a pony with god powers, originally being represented by the fact she had the qualities of all pony-kind. However, in also taking the role of her sister when she was banished to the moon, she had to use her powers 24-7. Probably unbeknownst to her, her powers grew.

Going with the theory that she wanted her sister back, but cannot use the Elements of Harmony to save her due to her increasingly being able to connect with her subjects on a more personal level (this blame goes to both sides, they worship her and her old memories of being a normal pony fading) she stages her disappearance (for all we know she is the one who wrote those legends [link] ).

Nightmare Moon is released, assuming the spell that locked her their only lasted as long as Celestia had power (As if she was constantly using her energy, as suppose to have formed a timed spell instead). So at that moment she thought Celestia was powerless.

Then using another favorite theory of mine, Twi and the others managed to destroy the dark mass (of what, Aku?) that was possessing Luna (the reason Celestia couldn't use the Elements of Harmony to get rid of it before was because one of the elements was Luna herself).

When her sister returned and her powers no longer constantly used, all of this unused energy started building up. Her original form can't handle it, so it tries to transform into something that can.

In trying to balance this, she tries to use her powers against herself to try to keep her 'original' form. Using yet another favorite theory of mine, She has Twilight (and perhaps other lesser students) write her reports on friendship, to help her relate and remember what it was like before she was a god.

But in the end, it doesn't work. Close subjects and others start seeing sides of her they cannot understand. Like how quite a few of you guys said how 'evil' she looks (fangs are cute guys, really), the same holds for the ponies who start thinking she is either possessed by evil or is evil.

Playing with the idea that many ponies are racist (not intentionally so) they would not accept her as ruler if they did not think she was a pony (which is on it's basics was already hypocritical, but work with me here). A rebellion of sorts starts. A very chaotic one at that as many ponies cannot decide where they stand (Celestia is evil, Celestia is not evil but possessed, She is good, She is a monster, etc).

Celestia cannot process nor handle it. Ordering others who are not faithful like Twilight now gives the impression of a threat and worse. Ponies attack her, her powers grandeur than what she herself realizes, easily overwhelms them. It only gets messier from there.

Twilight, as faithful as always, keeps to her mentors side while trying to keep the peace. Luna, as sister to Celestia must hide and behind the scenes because those against Celestia think of her as a 'monster' like Celestia (that, and all of the paranoia fuel from the legends as well). However, unbeknownst to her there is another group who is planning to have Luna take the 'crown' as a true queen...

:icondiscordumadplz: EDIT EDIT:
Concept cover: [link] The comic will be called Vast.

While the story is still very WIP, I know I will need a lot of OCs to represent the reaction of Equestria and the separate adventures of the girls. So if you would like your OC to have a crazy adventure and perhaps die horribly, please share here: [link] !! :eager:

Also ~clu2415 would like to remind that pouring damages books. Sorry for the error! XP

:iconreallylikehermaneplz: MORE EDITS: :excited:
~DotRook drew their take of my Celestia god (and her take on Luna)! [link]
~Fangirl-45 Has a mini fanfiction version of this comic! [link]
*Luigi-Mario Wrote their take on the aftermath: [link]
Can somepony tell me who drew this? [link]
~BrutalityInc [link] Please tell me you write for a living.

Characters © HasBRO + Lauren Faust
Comic © Lilithnanhart
Add a Comment:
CMoney31 Featured By Owner Sep 9, 2015
Suddenly, Nightmare Moon appears... Or is it Nightmare Moon? Looks a little darker that her, consisting of a finer black and different shades of black replace the original patterns.
The dark alicorn figure: "I am more than a rock in the sky. I am what looks into your dreams, into a world more vast and far more violent than you think dear sister. You see a worlds of the real, as I've entered into worlds of the unreal."
The room begins to darken, and twilight is pulled from Solar Flare.
Solar Flare: "Luna?"
The dark figure: "Not quite..." The figure brightens itself, "I am Nightmare Moon's power recreated in my image. You produce light, and darkness overpowers light."
the darkness purely surrounds Solar Flare, and consumes her. Solar flare is brought to a dark space, left floating without power. Celestia is seen floating next to Solar Flare, but she remains unconscious.
Solar Flare: "What is this?"
Celestia begins to light on fire, as if she's falling towards a sun. Luna zips to Celestia, and saves the Princess of the sun from a fiery doom as it is revealed that Celestia was falling into the sun. Solar Flare isn't stopping though. Solar Flare enters into the sun, and ends up in a room. The room has a dark cloud in a corner near a door.
Voices: "The corruption." "It awaits it's victim."
Luna: "Well, these "parties" that you seem to talk about. They would sound nicer if they were mostly held in the beauty of the night! Doesn't that sound just fantastic, sister!"
Celestia: "Hm. Well, you do tire of everyone sleeping through the darkness of the night. The hours that you watch over. You do grow lonesome, so I shall hold some of my parties under your hours! Does that satisfy you?"
Luna: "Indeed! Many thanks!"
Celestia walks away as Luna enters her room and closes the door. The dark cloud strikes into Luna's mind and fills her thoughts and powers with sadness, anger, and hate.
Luna: "Who Dare Fill My Head With Lies! The Dwellers Of The Day Will Soon See The Beauty Of Night, And I Will Not Fall To Evil! I Will Not Become Like Sombra Or Discord! Ghhhhhhhhh-" The darkness fills Luna's head with more thoughts, "I WILL DROWN EQUESTRIA IN MY ETERNAL NIGHT!!!" The voice echoes
Solar Flare then sees the moon's surface, but it has a creature standing on it. The creature wears a white suit, with Nightmare Moon standing next to it.
NM: "You 'humans' seem confusing. You rage wars simply because of difference in color?"
the creature: "Well, not exactly. It's also several other differences like difference in beliefs. What some think is right, others might not think the same way. Hell, the nation that I'm part of is in a struggle with another nation over the power of our weapons."
NM: "And... Hm. May I join you, and see your world? Maybe your world can help me with problems that I have. Please, Mr. Armstrong?"
Neil Armstrong: "We'll if your abilities can help you hide in my suit, then you've got a deal."
The words echo at random as the room changes to the place where Nightmare Moon was defeated by the mane six. Solar Flare stands at the stairwell, and the dark figure stands at the otherside of the room with an unconscious Twilight next to it. The dark figure stares at Solar Flare with eyes colored with shades of black.
The dark figure: "Leave this mind, and never come back Solar Flare. Even if it means killing the real Celestia, I won't let you harm this youngling for she bares a power far greater than ours. But you will never see that day, as I will make sure of it. Go now, or be destroyed. The choice remains yours."
The dark figure lies down next to Twilight, and lies it's head on her unconscious body.
Dragonjek Featured By Owner Sep 6, 2015  Hobbyist Writer
"Because I have the hardest time trying to foal myself into believing a moon can withstand the sun, let alone magical pony interpretations of it. That, and I love the theories of Princess Celestia being a tyrant and unable to understand friendship given her position as a literal god for hundreds of years (not that I don't enjoy the calm/giving leader side as well, episode 26 ftw)."

I personally never thought it made sense for the MLP sun to be a 9 nonillion kilogram ball of gas. We know Equestria is flat because they actually raise and lower the celestial bodies. By all measure that we've seen, Luna and Celestia are about equal. Additionally, just a group of unicorns was enough to move both heavenly bodies, and I don't think even every unicorn in the world together would be enough to move Earth's Sun. I think it just makes more sense for the sun and moon to be about the same size.

That aside, Luna holds power over darkness. However much it appears that light can chase it away, darkness existed before the suns were born and will exist after they have been snuffed out. There is certainly room for an entity of darkness to stand equally against an entity of light. And then there's Nightmare Moon to consider--a corruption that may very well be providing access to power from an outside source would more than even the playing field.

Not to mention that if we are saying that Equestria's sun work just like ours, then it is a star--and Luna raises (visible) stars by the millions every night.

Please note that I'm not trying to contradict your headcanon, just provide a reason for you to make sense of why the show and a lot of other artists/authors think that way.
lazerbem Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2015
Luna is weaker than Celestia. Even when she's all juiced up as Nightmare Moon, she only won her battle because Celestia wasn't putting her heart into it. Celestia didn't shoot back even once, she was playing purely defensively. She might have still won in a head to head battle, but it's abundantly clear that Celestia is the better flier by far
Dragonjek Featured By Owner Nov 3, 2015  Hobbyist Writer
That doesn't say anything, because precisely as you say--Celestia didn't try to actually match Luna's power. Focusing solely on defense will naturally make that defense stronger, and we got absolutely no measure of Celestia's offensive abilities.
lazerbem Featured By Owner Nov 3, 2015
Celestia was not focusing on defense, she was focused on not fighting at all. This is due to the fact that she doesn't want to hurt Luna. 

In any case, at the very least Celestia has combat feats. She almost beat Chrysalis and has dark magic, Luna never demonstrated any kind of feat aside from taking down a Celestia who did not want to fight or an offguard Celestia.
Dragonjek Featured By Owner Edited Sep 6, 2015  Hobbyist Writer
I would like to see Celestia's reaction when she sees just what she looks like--and how horrifically threatening she looks--to Twilight right now. Considering how injured Twilight looks, I don't suppose she'll be too pleased with herself.

If Celestia isn't evil, what's with the "Solar Flare" business?
deleteend Featured By Owner May 28, 2015
Very neat villain form for Celestia, quite impressive. I'll agree on the headcanon that seeing so many ponies die over the centuries probably hasn't been the best for Celestia's mind.
jantoniusz Featured By Owner May 9, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
You frightened me! :D
mikalover139 Featured By Owner May 2, 2015
For once, MLP actually seems interesting and makes sense.
JosephRaszagal Featured By Owner Apr 25, 2015
I have no idea where you plan on taking this, but your art by its own merits is fantastic.

Superb job, yo.
reiler12 Featured By Owner Apr 2, 2015
So mercenaries Team fortress appear putting bullet in the creature.
ZombieFX Featured By Owner Feb 21, 2015
knew - it
Houston12 Featured By Owner Oct 23, 2014
I DO understand what you're trying to do here. The ruler removed from empathy and such. While I do not personally enjoy this headcanon, your depiction is rather interesting. On another note, while do understand what you're trying to get across, its really hard to see, in this image at least, anything but a monstrous or at least threatening being. The visuals, rather sudden transformations, the wording, and Twilight's expression all contribute quite a bit to it. The explanation you gave helped sort out quite a few things though. I'll keep an eye on this, its peeked my interest.
...yesCoffee Break.
VirTaAshi Featured By Owner Apr 26, 2014
Since Twilight is now an Alicorn, Imagine the possibilities.
bruiser128 Featured By Owner Mar 29, 2014  Student Traditional Artist
Well from what I can tell I can say this with certainty. To even THINK about taking on this Uber powered Celestia
you need to be wield the power of something like this…
weeya1 Featured By Owner Mar 18, 2014
I love your art design!!!!!

(And it is very scary)

And cool!
Wolfboy183 Featured By Owner Feb 27, 2014
Kureiogen Featured By Owner Feb 24, 2014  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Holy ponytail! o.o
That`s intense.
Dragonsrose19 Featured By Owner Dec 30, 2013
We all knew she was secretly evil
Lordoffantasy Featured By Owner Dec 23, 2013
only problem with this idea is that............ well, the sun is NOT like our sun in mlp. it is clearly something far smaller and around the same size as the moon.
not to metnion her power does not have to be equivalent to the sun, for she is NOT the sun, only it regent. the sun does not need celestia and celestia, likely, does not need to sun to be powerful.
HatiChantheWolfHog Featured By Owner Nov 12, 2013
By that logic Luna would be more powerful because she raises the stars as well as the moon.
lazerbem Featured By Owner Oct 20, 2013
Discord I think could still handle her. Celestia would've had no reason to hold back against him yet he swatter her like a fly with no effort and then took control of the Sun like it was nothing
Chaos51268 Featured By Owner Oct 5, 2013  Student Traditional Artist
ShadowPaint-LisaM Featured By Owner May 25, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
That smile when she admits there wasn't a power struggle...... That smile is creepy as all hell.... Nice job regardless.
Nanhart Featured By Owner Jun 13, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Thank you. ^^
hunhplz Featured By Owner May 17, 2013
I for one would love to see Celestia in this form hugging her little student... Maybe a lick from her tongue can heal a wound instantly... :meow:
StGeorge7903 Featured By Owner Sep 2, 2014
I guess I would kind of like to see that, too. (Just the licking thing, though. From the description, Celestia seems majorly OP as is, and it's only gonna get worse.)


After Celestia sees Twilight freaking out, she tries to get Twilight to calm down by licking her. (A pony of Celestia's stature probably wouldn't be able to give a reasonable hug, so...)

And then Twilight gets even more freaked out. ("Oh, please, no, no...not like this.") Naturally, Celestia just stops and puts Twilight down.

Cue guards.

"Guards! Take Twilight to a medic! NOW!"

Cue more screaming.
Nanhart Featured By Owner May 17, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
And then multiple limbs grow where the wound was. 8D
hunhplz Featured By Owner May 18, 2013
Ooooooh... I'd love to see that... >:3
CatsTuxedo Featured By Owner May 16, 2013  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I have to say, the idea of the Princesses being able to turn into dragons is quite appealing ;)
VulpineSnow Featured By Owner Apr 30, 2013
... Some strange part of me wants to see Cosmic-Horror!Celestia comforting Twilight even in this form, not just holding her in her mane. :lol: I'm weird, I know.
MoppyPuppy Featured By Owner Apr 6, 2013
A lot of you are probably thinking: "Brutal?" "MLP?" "What's Brutal MLP?"

Nanhart Featured By Owner Apr 7, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I wouldn't call this brutal, but as long as you're having fun I have no complaints. ^^
MoppyPuppy Featured By Owner Apr 7, 2013
Nanhart Featured By Owner Apr 8, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
There's my one true love. :iconiloveyouplz:
clu2415 Featured By Owner Apr 6, 2013
*pores over books. Pouring over books ruins them. Poring over books is to study them intently.
Nanhart Featured By Owner Apr 7, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
That is quite true.
clu2415 Featured By Owner Apr 7, 2013
I had meant to also mention that this comic is really cool, but I hit reply too soon. :)
Nanhart Featured By Owner Apr 7, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Haha, the critic inside needs to make sure the correction is made! :XD:

Thank you. Glad the silly error didn't ruin it for you.
yefta03 Featured By Owner Mar 9, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Resident pony 7 last boss
in mission : The truth Behind friendship
Mission objective : kill celestia
darkdoomer Featured By Owner Feb 14, 2013  Professional Digital Artist
you are my little dino~
don't you know you're my very best preeeyyy !
LordOmegaZ Featured By Owner Jan 1, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
so celestia still cares for her loyal student? ;3
Nanhart Featured By Owner Jan 1, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I certainly like thinking so! XD
LordOmegaZ Featured By Owner Jan 2, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
me too :3

twilight: a..are you going to devour me princess? D: *still bleeding*
AutumnMiracles Featured By Owner Dec 30, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I agree with you, i dont get how people think that Celestia is "evil", for example, in the canterlot wedding episode, she said "I will protect my subjects, from you!"
HOW is that evil??

(i LOVE your concept, by the way, its very detailed, and me, being a fan of mythology, loves the idea! cant wait to see more of it :))
Nanhart Featured By Owner Dec 30, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Outside of this comic, I can understand why people like teasing the idea of a corrupt Celestia. After all, we hardly know her. What made Luna and herself the way they are complete mysteries aside from little historic blips here and there every season. They are ripe to any speculation the fandom can come up with. What miffed me was how many people were assuming antagonist in this comic based only on how sharp her teeth were becoming. >3<

(Thank you very much! For the compliment, faves and watch! I hope the story will be good enough to make up for the lousy updates!)
AutumnMiracles Featured By Owner Dec 30, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
My theory is that the writers leave their background open like that, so the bronies can come up with their own stories and comics ^^ just like you are doing. Those writers really do love us :XD:
And i love your idea about how Celestia has all this power that she cant handle, never seen anything like it! Its very unique, and i bet its going to be one of the best stories out there :)
(in my opinion, it already is :D theres no need to thank me ^^)
Nanhart Featured By Owner Dec 31, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
That's not theory, that's basic 101 story balance. XD Leaving things open is always the safest way to play when it comes to stories that have large staff with restrictions. Leads to less arguments internally and with publishers. And with the internet helping the fandoms get closer to the creators it also safer in that regard to avoid flame wars. Even with that in mind, the FiM team and Hasbro are miracle workers still~ ==

I'm a little baffled that no one has tried this yet! But original ideas only go so far, it's in the delivery if I manage to make this work or not. (Yes there is, thank you!)
AutumnMiracles Featured By Owner Dec 31, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
lol, then my theory is good :XD:
but still, i hope there is a episode to where we see how our Princesses came to be. I also hope that Lauren Faust will come back...

same here! i sure hope you do, because im really interested in this storyline.
(was about to say plot, but thought twice about it :XD:)
Add a Comment:


Submitted on
June 11, 2011
Image Size
1.7 MB


56,107 (12 today)
1,483 (who?)